Peanut Butter Archives - Page 2 of 7

Peanut Butter Maple Chip Scones

With my lifetime of baking, there are a lot of recipes that I think back on and remember loving. But also with all those memories of recipes, I sometimes second guess whether they were as good as I remember. These scones are one of those second guesses. I remember being obsessed with them when I…

PB&J Layer Cake (Brown Butter Cake, Cherry Compote, Cinnamon Crumb, and Peanut Butter Frosting)

My brother is turning THIRTY this Monday, so we’ve been celebrating all weekend. That means making a cake for us to enjoy the whole weekend. My brother’s golden birthday cake last year was a pretty spectacular cake, so the bar was set high this year. His only request was “PB&J,” but I was able to…

Reese’s Oreo Cookies

I’ve made a grand total of $50 from this blog in the past 12-13 years. But I will treat it like it’s my job when there’s a new grocery store dessert product released. It’s my professional duty to try them and see if they can be baked with. In this case: the Reese’s and Oreo…

Peanut Butter Milk Bar Pie Bars

I’ve had the idea for these Peanut Butter Milk Bar Pie Bars written down for a while, ever since I was brainstorming ideas for State Fair bakes. This one could have fit in the “layered bars, no lemon” category, but I went with something else (which was also delicious). But I still wanted to make…

Peanut Butter Brownie Ice Cream

This recipe probably didn’t need it’s own post, because it’s incredibly simple and I made it just to use up some brownie scraps I had. But… I wanted to show off my new pottery! And I also have said before that I consider this more of a baking diary than a blog! Peanut Butter Brownie…

Chocolate PB Cookie Bars

There’s an Instagram reel that has been fed into my algorithm approximately 700 times, and it’s for these sugar cookie bars that look very tasty. But, I’ve gone to their website, and they do not have the recipe posted! I believe they have some sort of paid subscription thing in order to get access to…

Peanut Butter Milk Bar Pie (Happy Pi Day!)

My first memories of pi day are, unfortunately, not great. It was one of the many times during my childhood education where learning the concept of something did not exactly pan out in practice. It’s up there with the time I was told we’d be doing an experiment where we “make clouds” inside of 2-liter…

PB&J Monster Cookies

Sometimes I feel like the grocery store is out of control. And I’m not just talking about prices. I’m talking about the number of items available. Companies just will not stop coming up with things. In the past week alone, I’ve seen Cinnamon Toast Crunch Hershey Kisses, Butterbeer Goldfish, bunny-shaped Reese’s Puffs, and PB&J M&Ms….

thebatterthickens